Optimizing Interconnect vs. VPN: Latency, Throughput, and Real-World Use Cases on Google Cloud

As organizations modernize their infrastructure, migrating from traditional datacenters to cloud-native platforms, network connectivity becomes a central architectural decision. And on Google Cloud, one of the most common debates among experienced leaders is:

Should we use Interconnect or VPN to connect our on-prem or WAN to the cloud?

This isn’t a simple pricing comparison. It’s a decision that impacts:

• Latency
• Throughput
• Reliability
• Security
• Hybrid workloads
• Disaster recovery
• Data transfer strategies
• Future scalability

If your business runs mission-critical systems, builds multi-region architectures, or supports global customers, choosing the right connection method directly affects performance, downtime risk, and operational experience.

Let’s break this down deeply and practically.

---

1. Setting the Stage: Why Connectivity Matters More Today

In the early cloud days, enterprises used VPN primarily as a secure tunnel from on-prem to cloud. It was simple, inexpensive, and enough for low-traffic workloads.

But as cloud adoption matured, businesses started pushing far more demanding requirements:

• High-throughput data pipelines
• Latency-sensitive applications
• Real-time analytics
• Distributed microservices
• Hybrid database replication
• Cross-region failover
• Global service architectures

At this stage, VPN suddenly becomes a bottleneck.

This is where Interconnect—Google’s private, high-speed connection—enters the story.

But choosing between the two depends not only on speed, but also your business model, your workloads, and your long-term roadmap.

---

2. A Clear Breakdown: What Is VPN vs. What Is Interconnect?

Before diving into architecture decisions, let’s define them side-by-side.

What Is a Google Cloud VPN?

A secure IPSec tunnel that connects your on-prem/branch to Google Cloud.

• Uses the public internet
• Encrypted tunnel through IPSec
• Quick to configure
• Low to moderate throughput
• Moderate latency (depends on internet routing)
• Highly cost-effective

GCP offers:

• Classic VPN
• HA VPN (High Availability VPN with SLA-backed reliability)

---

What Is Google Cloud Interconnect?

A high-bandwidth, private physical connection between your network and Google.

Two types:

1. Dedicated Interconnect

A physical port directly into Google’s edge, offering:

• 10 Gbps or 100 Gbps per link
• Up to 200 Gbps aggregate per VLAN
• Lowest latency possible

2. Partner Interconnect

Connectivity via a Google Cloud partner:

• More flexible bandwidth options (50 Mbps to 50 Gbps)
• Easier provisioning
• Suitable for remote/global locations

Interconnect doesn’t send traffic over the public internet—it uses Google’s private backbone.

---

3. Latency: How Much Does It Really Matter?

Latency isn’t only a number—it’s a business outcome.

For some businesses, shaving 20–30 milliseconds doesn’t matter.
For others, it changes everything.

Let’s compare.

VPN Latency

• Travels over public internet
• Variable based on ISP routing
• Unpredictable during congestion
• Latency spikes during peak hours
• Higher jitter

Real-world ranges: 30–150 ms, depending on geography.

VPN latency is rarely stable because you don’t control the network path.

---

Interconnect Latency

• Traffic enters Google’s network as early as possible
• Google’s private backbone carries it end-to-end
• Predictable, low-jitter connectivity

Real-world ranges: 2–20 ms between your datacenter and Google’s PoPs.

Mission-critical latency matters when you’re running:

• Live bidding platforms
• Video streaming platforms
• Financial trading systems
• Real-time gaming
• Hybrid transactional databases
• Global microservices

If latency changes your performance metrics or customer experience, Interconnect is the solution.

---

4. Throughput: The Real Bottleneck in Hybrid Architectures

Throughput determines how much data you can move—and how fast.

VPN Throughput

VPN is constrained by:

• IPSec processing overhead
• Internet throughput limits
• Single-tunnel bandwidth limitations

HA VPN improves reliability, but throughput still tops out at:

• ~3–10 Gbps (multiple tunnels)
• Often less in real-world conditions

Sufficient for:

• Control-plane traffic
• Occasional data transfers
• Small-to-medium workloads

Not suitable for:

• Terabyte-scale analytics pipelines
• BigQuery batch transfers
• Hybrid storage syncing
• High-volume backups
• ML data ingestion
• Massive replication streams

---

Interconnect Throughput

Dedicated Interconnect offers:

• 10 Gbps or 100 Gbps per link
• LAG (link aggregation) for scaling
• Partner Interconnect offering 50 Mbps → 50+ Gbps options

In high-throughput architectures, Interconnect becomes critical:

• Multi-terabyte daily ETL
• Streaming data into Pub/Sub
• BigQuery ingestion from datacenter
• Hybrid applications like SAP
• Active/Active multi-region deployments
• High-volume media content movement

Interconnect isn’t just faster—it makes large-scale architectures operationally feasible.

---

5. Reliability and SLAs: Where the Business Case Gets Stronger

VPN Reliability

VPN depends on:

• Internet routing stability
• ISP reliability
• Tunnel failovers
• Cloud router BGP stability

HA VPN significantly improves uptime with:

• 99.99% SLA
• Automatic failover tunnels
• Dual gateways

But VPN is still subject to the public internet’s unpredictability.

---

Interconnect Reliability

Dedicated Interconnect offers:

• 99.9% to 99.99% SLAs depending on redundancy
• Dual-homed connections (Highly Recommended)
• Private, deterministic routing
• Stable throughput
• Better failover consistency

When your network cannot go down, Interconnect wins by a wide margin.

---

6. Security: Both Are Secure, but Not Equal

VPN Security

• IPSec encrypted
• Traverses public internet
• Requires strong key rotation and policies
• Vulnerable to ISP outages or routing issues

Ideal for secure tunnels, but not ideal for highly sensitive workloads.

---

Interconnect Security

• Private physical connection
• Never traverses public internet
• Data flows into Google’s private backbone
• Integrates seamlessly with VPC Service Controls
• Lower attack surface

For regulated industries—finance, healthcare, telecom—Interconnect simplifies compliance.

---

7. Cost Considerations: It’s Not About Price Alone

Cost is a major factor, but the decision shouldn’t be based purely on price.

VPN Costs

Very low.
Typically:

• Per-hour pricing for cloud VPN gateways
• Minimal data transfer fees

Best for small teams, development workloads, or low-throughput apps.

---

Interconnect Costs

Higher upfront, but not always expensive long-term.

Costs include:

• Port fees
• Cross-connect fees (at colocation site)
• Data transfer (lower than internet egress)
• Provisioning or partner cost (for Partner Interconnect)

But Interconnect often reduces egress costs compared to public internet pricing.

For companies moving petabytes annually, Interconnect is often cheaper than VPN.

---

8. Real-World Use Cases: When to Use VPN vs Interconnect

You can’t choose correctly without looking at practical scenarios.

---

When VPN is the Better Choice

1. Small or early-stage deployments

Proof of concept
Development environments
Light workloads

2. Remote offices or branch connections

Low bandwidth
Event-driven workloads
User authentication traffic

3. Backups and administrative connections

Monitoring
Control-plane operations
Occasional data movement

If cost is the biggest concern and performance isn’t critical—VPN works.

---

When Interconnect is the Better Choice

1. High-throughput hybrid workloads

You need consistent bandwidth for:

• ETL jobs
• Data lake ingestion
• ML model training
• Media encoding

2. Latency-sensitive architectures

Such as:

• Distributed microservices
• Game servers
• Financial trading systems

3. Hybrid transactional databases

For example:

• On-prem Oracle <-> GCP
• Cloud SQL read replicas
• Spanner multi-region sync pipelines

4. Compliance or regulatory requirements

Interconnect simplifies:

• PCI
• HIPAA
• FFIEC
• Banking regulations

5. Large enterprises with strict SLAs

If uptime is contractual, Interconnect gives control and predictability.

---

9. Combining Both: The Best of Both Worlds

Many mature organizations use both Interconnect and VPN.

Typical pattern:

• Interconnect as the primary path (high speed, low latency)
• HA VPN as backup failover
• Cloud Router handles BGP-based routing decisions
• Traffic switches automatically

This creates a hybrid network with:

• Redundancy
• High throughput
• Reliable failover
• Lower latency
• No single points of failure

This is the architecture recommended for mission-critical workloads.

---

10. Making the Decision: A Simple Framework for Leaders

To choose the right connectivity method, ask:

A. What is your required throughput?

< 5 Gbps → VPN may be fine

5 Gbps → Interconnect recommended
20 Gbps → Interconnect required
100 Gbps → Dedicated Interconnect only

B. How sensitive are you to latency?

Latency-critical workloads always prefer Interconnect.

C. How much data will move between on-prem and GCP?

Petabyte-scale = Interconnect
Moderate or unpredictable = Possibly VPN + caching

D. Do you have compliance obligations?

Private connectivity often simplifies audits.

E. How mature is your cloud environment?

Proof of concept → VPN
Enterprise migration → Interconnect
Two-way hybrid architecture → Interconnect + VPN failover

---

Final Thoughts

Choosing between Interconnect and VPN isn’t just a networking choice—it’s a strategic infrastructure decision that shapes your cloud architecture, performance, and operational resilience.

VPN is flexible, quick, inexpensive, and perfect for low-volume or development scenarios.

Interconnect is built for speed, low latency, reliability, and high-throughput hybrid architectures.

For modern enterprises aiming for predictable performance, strong SLAs, and future scalability, Interconnect becomes the clear backbone. And when combined with HA VPN for redundancy, it forms a rock-solid connectivity strategy that supports mission-critical workloads on Google Cloud.